When social media first entered the legal marketing arena, it was met with a slew of naysayers and timid acceptance. For the legal universe, notoriously behind the times in technological advances, this seemed far too complex to pitch to wary attorneys who already had enough on their plates with billable hours, hectic schedules and the ever present push to grow their book of business. As luck would have it, the legal world has since embraced social media and learned the power of its network-expanding potential and general ease of use. But, with evolving platforms being released all the time, when do we cry uncle and draw the line on what is and is not valuable to a legal marketing practice? The concept has been highly debated in recent years, and the veteran sites (LinkedIn, Facebook, Twitter, and more recently, Google+) have stood the test of time. And now, enter stage right: Pinterest. This vastly popular, visually-charged social media platform is sweeping the nation, amidst an onslaught of legal and copyright related reservations, even outside of the law firm realm. Which all begs the question: is it really worth it to push your law firm's brand on Pinterest?
Each of the successful social media platforms seems to have found its niche market. LinkedIn provides a professional environment with which to network without ever leaving one's desk, providing pertinent information for both internal firm relations, potential client research, and reconnecting with old contacts; Facebook, being very valuable for some firms and practice groups in a networking stance if its key client base is highly engaged therein, is used primarily for recruiting and brand management in other firms. A few years ago, many firms refused to accept Facebook as a viable networking tool, due to its origination as a university-based forum used mainly for sharing personal information; today, many firms use it successfully for brand management. Twitter allows firms to engage their clients on a real-time, short-burst interaction basis, and is valuable for firms that have a heavy focus on SEO. Google+ seems to have been poorly utilized as a networking tool, but since Google's algorithm rules the universe, many firms are still choosing to use it in hopes that the SEO benefits will be worth the time invested. The new kid on the block, Pinterest, is virtually an online scrapbook where users compile groupings of images (with attributed links to the original source and the associated content therein). It has been touted as being incredibly useful for wedding planning, kitchen and other home renovations, wardrobe and fashion choices, and other popular topics. If you have never used Pinterest, please check out thePinterest Beginners' Guide for a step-by-step explanation of how it works.
I firmly believe that you must decide three things before delving into a firm or brand-related Pinterest account: 1) who is your target audience?, 2) is this a beneficial use of marketing time?, and 3) are you well informed on the copyright issues beginning to arise from Pinterest use, and are you willing to deal with the aftermath? While those seem like no-brainer strategic planning questions that should be considered before all marketing endeavors, they seem to be especially pertinent with this platform. The vast majority (97%) of Pinterest users are women; ironically, a very high percentage of legal marketers are also female. If your target client base falls into that category (for example, a Family Law practice might be a good fit) then it might make sense to have a presence on a social media platform that is almost exclusively used by women.
Our society is rapidly embracing visually stimulated media, which is evidenced by the explosion of Smartphone photography applications, such as Instagram, in expressing their interests. Beyond that, Pinterest is a great way to organize blogs, articles, and other infographics into one neat location where you can find, share, and keep track of information pertinent to your practice areas and attorneys. If you Pin a photo of each attorney under a Board titled "Our Lawyers", each photo could link back to his/her bio page on your website (thusly, driving traffic to your site). If you were to task a specific attorney with managing one of the practice area-specific Boards, he/she could Pin relevant blog entries from other attorneys, news articles on hot legal topics, or simply white papers that the firm has written on a topic. As far as business development efforts go, an "Our Clients" Board could contain Pins of client's brands, photos, or other links that would further the client's marketing efforts, as well as show the relationship therein. The hope would be that if the client has a presence on Pinterest, they would in turn Pin your brand efforts on their board, and your network would expand further to their followers. There are clear ways to use Pinterest within the parameters of your current social media and online marketing efforts, and I'm sure as time goes on more will become evident.
Another possible tactic is to use the rapidly popular "humanizing the attorney" marketing method, allowing attorneys to post on personal Pinterest pages (or Boards within the firm's page) products, books, vacation spots, etc. that they like. This would be in hopes that a potential or current client finds a common ground with the attorney, thusly forming the "trusted advisor" bond that many lawyers hope to achieve. On the flip side, some clients may not care to share their likes and dislikes with their attorney, and the oversharing of information may be misconstrued or considered unnecessary. Again, this is not a one-size-fits-all-firms situation. Do your own due diligence as to what would work best in your firm's culture. Also, remember that some attorneys will only invest time in efforts that translate directly to ROI; others see the bigger picture benefit of showcasing their expertise in a less measurable fashion, and in the act of having a presence being a valuable enough metric.
On the flip side, there are several obvious negatives. First, the ever present struggle against the clock: do you have the time/manpower within your staff/energy to follow through with yet another social media outlet to the point where it is worthwhile and beneficial to business development and brand management? If the answer is no, it might be wise to hold off and see if other firms find success in its use before you fold it into your social media plan. Like many have said, there are only so many hours in the day, and only so many of those can be dedicated to social media efforts. If you don't have a specific strategy for how you will measure success in this instance (though it may be an unorthodox metric in this case), it may not be worth the time and effort invested in the ongoing project.
The second drawback, which is rapidly becoming newsworthy, is regarding the copyright issues noted in Pinterest's Terms of Use. It is expected that a user will ensure that each and every Pin on their Boards is attributed to the original author, lest they violate the terms and can face prosecution therein. Where rapid Re-Pinning occurs, it is easy to lose the trail along the way, and with one click you may enter into a situation you don't even realize is violating the Terms. In a brilliant article by Gina Rubel of Furia Rubel Communications, she cites that according to Business Insider, "users must have explicit permission from the owner to post everything." This wouldn't pose a problem with original firm content, but anything beyond that could pose a problem depending on how stringent the rules are. While there hasn't been much in the way of litigation on these matters yet, the hot topic of debate may rear its ugly head down the road. With all of the ethics issues surrounding online legal marketing to begin with, it's all a matter of whether or not you think it is worth taking the risk.
Pinterest is indubitably a worthwhile organizational social media tool, and has been proven valuable in many companies' brand management efforts. However, as far as its beneficial use in law firm marketing is concerned, I believe the jury is still out.
By Jenna O'Connor, Director of Marketing, Rosenberg Martin Greenberg, LLP for the May/June 2012 Issue of the Capital Ideas Newsletter.